- What is a life insurance contestability clause?
- January 15, 2014
The life insurance contestability cause is a short window in which insurance companies can investigate and deny claims. The period is two years in most states and one year in others, and it begins as soon as a policy goes into effect.
If you should die while the policy is contestable and under questionable circumstances, the insurance company will thoroughly investigate the claim before they will release any proceeds to your beneficiaries, explains Edward E. Graves, insurance expert and author of “McGill’s Life Insurance.”
An insurance denial based on the contestability clause is far more common than you think.
In fact, everyone – regardless of wealth or social status – is subjected to the same contestability period. Distribution of their life insurance proceeds to their beneficiaries is under the scrutiny of the life insurer if something happens to them before the contestability period ends.
A good example of this is actor Heath Ledger.
In Ledger’s case, he died of a drug overdose in January 2008—just seven months after he bought the policy. This would be an instant red flag for an insurance company. His insurance company initially refused payment and claimed his death could have been a suicide, even though it had been ruled accidental. The company eventually settled the case for an undisclosed sum.
Although Ledger insured himself to the hilt with a $10 million policy, his life insurance company tried to toss those proceeds out through the contestability window after his death. As a standard part of any life insurance policy, the two-year contestability clause gives an insurer the right to challenge or even refuse a claim.
The contestability clause provides the insurance company with a window of time where it can dispute the validity of the contract if they suspect fraud, concealment or misrepresentation on the insurance application. If the life insurer has not rescinded or terminated the policy after the contestability period, they cannot rescind the policy or deny a claim.
“They can if they so desire, if they think that the circumstances are such, contest a death benefit up until two years after the issue date,” says Brian Ashe, Treasurer of the Life and Health Insurance Foundation. “Once they get beyond two years they can’t, so the contestability clause and the suicide clause begin all over again when they get a new contract.”
If Ledger’s case had been ruled a suicide, the company would’ve had the right to refuse payment to his beneficiaries because he died within the two-year contestability period. Likewise, if there had been any inaccurate or missing information on his application, the company could have denied payment to his beneficiaries even if the information had no impact on his death.
On the other hand, if Ledger had died after two years of buying that policy, the contestability clause would’ve no longer been in effect and payout would’ve been granted automatically—regardless of the manner of his death or any other issues.
The contestability clause is an often-overlooked part of life insurance, as few buyers would say they expect to die within then next two years. The Ledger case offers an example of why it’s important to understand its potential impact before buying a policy—and to be clear on how this issue is handled by a company and the policy it provides.
It’s worth your time to always ask about contestability clauses before buying a term life insurance policy since every contract and insurance company has different ways of handling the payout period of a death benefit.
“It’s important for customers to understand the contestability clause and what the provisions in the contract are in case the policyholder dies during that period,” says David Theile, Director in Life/Health Product Management at State Farm. “This insures they understand what circumstances might cause a death benefit not to be paid.”
- Category: Articles Library, Featured Story, Life Insurance, Videos
Life Insurance Quotes
Leave a Reply